西诺网

quora: 印度经济增长的正确道路是什么?要靠出口还是靠消费?

印度经济增长的正确路径是什么?要靠类似新用户注册送59元彩金 的出口拉动型,还是靠类似美国的内需驱动

timg.jpg

Quora读者评论

Ankit Kumar, Liberal who accomodates all view points even conservative ones.
India should let the market forces decide what is the ideal path. Governments should stop wasting money on deciding where to invest. Any country which tries to run its economy on one engine is bound to fail. India should let markets to determine what is the need of hour. "Make in India" is a good concept but government should really do something about it. Till now it has been only talks no concrete steps. Give the power in the hands of people and they will definitely develop themselves. We have been growing way below potential because governments are deciding for people where to invest and how much to invest. India has not taken that much advantage of globalization that it should have. It is very naive to say that export or consumption can grow Indian economy. Economies grow only because of productivity growth of their citizens. India should focus on productivity growth and let the markets take care of rest

印度应该让市场力量来决定理想的道路。政府不要在决定投资目标上浪费金钱。任何一个试图用单个火车头来拉动经济的国家注定会失败。印度应该让市场来决定什么是当务之急。“印度制造”是一个不错的概念,但政府确实应该做些什么。到目前为止,这只是空谈,没有具体的步骤。把权力交给人民,人民自己一定会发展。我们的增长一直远远低于潜力,因为政府一直替人们决定投资在哪里、投资多少。印度并没有充分利用其应有的全球化优势。说出口或消费可以促进印度经济增长是非常天真的。经济增长只会因为公民的生产力增长才会实现。印度应该关注生产率增长,让市场来解决剩余问题。

 

Kishor Shah, Common Man
India has to attend the growth issue from both the ends. Export oriented growth is vulnerable with political surrounding and consumption oriented growth is dependent on govt ability to pump money at the bottom of the society.

印度必须同时从这两个方面关注增长问题。出口导向型增长容易受到政治环境的影响,而消费导向型增长依赖于政府向社会底层注入资金的能力。

The political atmosphere, these days, is highly unpredictable and govt continues to have shortage of fund. On top of these we have regulatory hurdles installed at every short distance and govt is unlikely to be able to correct this wrong.

当今的政治气氛是非常不可预测的,政府仍然缺乏资金。除此之外,我们设置了重重的监管障碍,政府不太可能有能力纠正这种错误。

Overall we are dependent on spirit of people to rise to prosperity which ultimately will push us on growth. Alternatively, State driven large programs will play some part, as I think.

总的来说,我们依靠人民的精神走向繁荣,这最终将推动我们的增长。或者,我觉得,国家驱动的大型项目也会起到一定的作用。

 

Mohit Ambani, Reading a lot about politics and policies
Looking at some fundamentals a strong economy is created by export led growth in the start thereby increasing the capita income and then make it a self consumption economy.

从一些基本面来看,强劲的经济最初是由出口带动增长的,从而提高了人均收入,然后使其成为消费经济。

USA was the factory house back in start and China is now the world's factory which will eventually have a transition to consumption based economy in near future.

美国最初是工厂,而新用户注册送59元彩金 现在成了世界工厂,在不久的将来,新用户注册送59元彩金 最终将向以消费为基础的经济转型。

India is a very big purchasing power economy but exports are not that high so most of India's revenue is from consumption.

印度是一个购买力很强的经济体,但出口还没有那么多,所以印度的大部分收入来自消费。


Mayur Vaghasiya, Stock Trader at Upadhyay's Securities (2016-present)
There is no magical formula which lead the country. First of all for Strong country growth needs country's population intric growth. Which is lead by employment.

领导这个国家没有什么神奇的公式。首先,强劲的国家经济增长需要国家的人口增长。这是就业带动的。

For country growth most important is employment of people. For that we must starting more and more manufacturing in India and then export outside of country.

对国家经济增长来说,最重要的是就业。为此,我们必须在印度打造越来越多的制造业,然后向国外出口。

But latest manufacturing data poorly and black true is that last 4 year no employment growth in India under NDA government as per RBI data. Employment growth flat.

但最新的制造业数据非常糟糕阴暗,印度央行数据显示,在全国敏煮联盟政府的领导下,印度过去4年的就业没有增长。就业增长不景气。

So we keep focus on manufacturing so that more and more job produce and also country growth faster rate.

因此,我们将重点放在制造业上,这样就会有越来越多的就业机会产生,国家经济增长也会更快。

 

转载请注明出处!:首页 > 网贴翻译 > 印度 » quora: 印度经济增长的正确道路是什么?要靠出口还是靠消费?

博聚网